The Nicomekl River Dispute: A Tale of Boats, Buoys, and Blame

Sakchi Khandelwal
New Update

The 'Hole' in the Story


At the heart of a recent controversy lies a section of the Nicomekl River, colloquially known as 'The Hole'. Boat owners anchored in this area are currently disputing claims by the City of Surrey that they are moored illegally and responsible for environmental pollution. The city, in a recent news release, stated it plans to remove derelict boats that are illegally moored and dumping waste into the river. The boaters, however, argue that they have been unfairly accused and that the real pollution issue is the runoff from nearby cattle farms.

(Read Also: Indian-Americans Call for Action in Response to Hate Speech in Canada)

Sailing Through the Legalities


In response to the City of Surrey's claims, Transport Canada, which has jurisdiction over these waters, stated that the boats in question are not illegally moored. According to them, these vessels must adhere to the Wrecked Abandoned and Hazardous Vessels Act. The act outlines the responsibilities of boat owners and the repercussions of abandonment or dilapidation. Transport Canada plans to work with the boat owners to ensure their vessels do not become obstructions or fall into a state of disrepair, and to remove any vessels that have been abandoned.

Moving Buoys and Muddy Waters

Adding to the confusion are buoys with signs that indicate no anchoring and no mooring. According to the boaters, these buoys have drifted from their original positions over the years, in some cases by up to 100 meters, causing some of the Nicomekl boats to appear as if they are trespassing. The boaters argue that these misplaced buoys are contributing to the perception that they are moored illegally.


The Real Source of Pollution?

The boaters are also contesting the City of Surrey's claim that they are responsible for dumping raw sewage into the river. They argue that the real pollution issue is the sewage from the thousands of dairy cattle housed in barns near the shoreline. This runoff, they claim, creates a stench and causes an environmental problem, particularly noticeable at low tide.

(Also Read: US Secretary of State S. Jaishankar holds talks amid India-Canada conflict)


A Clean-Up on the Horizon

Despite the ongoing dispute, the City of Surrey has announced plans to begin cleaning up boats and debris from the river this month. The city has stated it will continue to collaborate with Transport Canada moving forward, as this matter falls under their jurisdiction. As part of this collaboration, the city will be removing derelict boats from the Nicomekl River and cleaning up any associated debris.

A Complex Issue

This dispute highlights the complexities surrounding maritime laws, environmental conservation, and local governance. It also underscores the importance of clear communication between all parties involved, as well as the need for accurate and regular monitoring of waterways to prevent such disputes in the future.

Read More