Advertisment

Book Censorship and Freedom of Expression: A Tale of Two Incidents

Two recent incidents in Quebec and Missouri have sparked fervent debates about book censorship, freedom of expression, and antisemitism. Dive into the complex issues surrounding literature and censorship, as society grapples with the responsibility that comes with the written word.

author-image
Muhammad Jawad
Updated On
New Update
Book Censorship and Freedom of Expression: A Tale of Two Incidents

Book Censorship and Freedom of Expression: A Tale of Two Incidents

In the annals of literature, books have often been the battleground for societal conflicts, serving as mirrors reflecting our deepest fears and prejudices. Two recent incidents, on either side of the border, underscore the contentious issue of book censorship, igniting fervent debates on freedom of expression and the troubling resurgence of antisemitism.

Advertisment

A Tale of Two Books

The first episode unfolds in Quebec, where the Jewish Public Library took the unprecedented step of removing 30 books authored by the writer-illustrator, Gravel, from its public shelves. The catalyst for this action was a series of social media posts by Gravel concerning the Israel-Hamas war, which were deemed inflammatory and potentially antisemitic.

These books, including titles like "The Great Antonio" and "Le Facteur Siffle," are now accessible only upon request, a decision that has sent ripples across the literary community. A city councillor from Côte-St-Luc, a suburb with a significant Jewish population, is contemplating similar measures.

Advertisment

The Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs has expressed grave concerns, stating that Gravel's posts are fanning the flames of antisemitism, a sentiment echoed by many in the Jewish community.

Fanning the Flames

The second incident transpired in Missouri, where Valentina Gomez, a Republican candidate for secretary of state, publicly burned a book titled "Naked: Not Your Average Sex Encyclopedia" by Daguzan Bernier, illustrated by Gariépy. Gomez claimed that the book, which addresses topics such as consent and contraception, was part of materials grooming and sexualizing children.

Advertisment

Gomez vowed to systematically destroy such books if elected, a stance that has drawn widespread criticism and concern from advocates of freedom of expression and sexual education.

Orca Book Publishers, the publisher of "Naked," defends the book as an essential resource for teens grappling with questions about sexuality, arguing that it provides accurate and age-appropriate information.

An Old Priest from the 1900s

Advertisment

Mathieu Lacombe, Quebec's culture minister, has denounced both incidents, likening them to actions reminiscent of "an old priest from the 1900s." He emphasized the importance of protecting freedom of expression and the right to access diverse literature.

According to a recent report by PEN America, around 1648 books were banned between 2021 and 2022 in the United States alone, a figure that underscores the urgency of this debate.

As we navigate this evolving landscape of literature and censorship, it is crucial to remember that books are more than mere objects; they are repositories of knowledge, mirrors of society, and catalysts for change. The ongoing debates about freedom of expression and antisemitism serve as a stark reminder of the power and responsibility that come with the written word.

In this battle for the soul of literature, the question that looms large is not just about what we choose to read, but also about what we allow to be written, published, and shared. As we grapple with these complex issues, let us strive to uphold the principles of freedom of expression, inclusivity, and respect for diverse viewpoints.

Advertisment
Advertisment