An unprecedented trial has taken place in Granma, Cuba, against six doctors accused of causing the death of a 23-year-old patient following a traffic accident in 2021. The trial, instigated by a family complaint, was held on November 21 and 22 at the People’s Provincial Court of Granma, marking a significant event in the history of Cuban health care.
The General Directorate of Public Health in Granma has defended the judicial process, confirming that the doctors remain free and have not been disqualified from practicing their profession. The fate of the doctors, however, hangs in the balance as they await a ruling from the Provincial Court. This decision, based on the evidence presented during the trial, can be appealed by the defendants before the Supreme People’s Court.
The accused doctors are Rafael José Sánchez Vázquez, Yoandra Quesada Labrada, Ristian Solano, Elizabeth Silvera, William Pérez Ramírez, and Henrry Rosales Pompa. All six doctors stand accused of medical negligence while trying to save the life of a motorcyclist who sustained multiple injuries in a traffic accident months ago.
However, the trial and the accusations have sparked widespread concern and rejection among medical personnel and the population due to the lack of resources in hospitals. The doctors, in their defense, have highlighted the inadequate conditions and limited resources they had to work with. This argument is echoed by urologist Aldo Luis Zamora Varona, who also worked at the ‘Carlos Manuel de Céspedes’ provincial hospital in Bayamo. According to Dr. Varona, the fault doesn't lie with the doctors but with the conditions under which they had to operate.
The case has attracted widespread attention, with social media users and organizations like Prisoners Defenders criticizing the lack of transparency from the authorities. They argue that the alleged negligence is a consequence of systemic failings in government management, not the incompetence of health professionals.